In October 2006 Microsoft and EMC announced a new enterprise content management alliance to enable organisations to become people-ready with their compliance, regulatory and other critical business data (
press release).
EMC has two products for Microsoft SharePoint:
- Archive Services for SharePoint: Allow users to archive content to Documentum.
- Content Services for SharePoint: Complete front-end for document management, using SharePoint’s interface.
SharePoint and Documentum technical comparison:
- Platform:
o SharePoint: Windows, SQL, .Net
o Documentum: Unix/Linux, Oracle, and Windows.
- Storage:
o SharePoint: SQL
o Documentum: SQL, Oracle, file system
- Office integration:
o SharePoint: full integration with SharePoint.
o Documentum: Light integration using Webtop application connector.
- Other applications integration:
o SharePoint: Possible, but not out of the box.
o Documentum: Partially, as it does with Office.
- Working offline:
o SharePoint: gives variety of mechanisms, i.e. Outlook and Groove.
o Documentum: Requires Documentum Desktop application.
- Rights Management:
o SharePoint: natively supported in Office.
o Documentum: Requires Information Rights Manager application.
- Security Model:
o SharePoint: Extensive permission levels with the ability to create customised groups.
o Documentum: More extensive permissions for allowing users perform specific functions.
- Repository:
o SharePoint: Internal content, external content (i.e. file systems) needs custom code.
o Documentum: Internal content and file systems.
Documentum is a document management system (or better say EMC) only and does not have SharePoint’s collaboration, business intelligence (i.e. KPI and BDC), business forms/workflows, enterprise search and portal functionalities.
Many of Documentum's features (i.e. archiving in seperate environment) can be achieved by a bit of custom coding or even advanced workflows using SPD.
Organisations need to consider what their content management requirements are and wisely choose between SharePoint and Documentum, or integrate both if their budget allows them.
Based on a recent
Gartner report published this September, Microsoft has driven the most change in the ECM market overt the past 18 months with WSS and MOSS. In the magic quadrant for ECM, Microsoft is in the top right quarter with IBM, EMC, Open Text and Oracle, but is leading in "completeness of vison" amongst all these vendors. And this is only for its content management.
Ali Sanaei
(You can automatically receive my blog posts by subscribing to this
RSS feed.)